Skip to main content.
OSUN Menu
Education sub-menu
Education
OSUN Courses
Faculty
Graduate Programs
Certificate Programs
Mobility
Teaching
Birkbeck Summer School
Center for Liberal Arts and Sciences Pedagogy (CLASP)
Developing Teaching Professionals
Experiential Learning Institute
Global History Lab
Global Teaching Fellowship Program
GLOBALED
Curricula
CORUSUS
Economic Democracy Initiative
Experimental Humanities Collaborative Network
Global Studies
Hannah Arendt Humanities Network
Human Rights Program
Liberal Arts and Sciences Collaborative
Policy Labs
Professional Development Program for University Administrators
Strengthening the Core
Transnational Feminism, Solidarity, and Social Justice
Research sub-menu
Research
Research Projects
Community Engaged Research
The Democracy Institute
Economic Democracy Initiative
GEOHUB
Global Institute of Advanced Study
OSUN Forum on Democracy and Development
Research Creation Initiative
Fellowships
Chatham House Academy Fellowships
Global Scholars Academy
Past Projects
Interruptrr
Global Observatory on Academic Freedom
Open Society Research Platform
Access sub-menu
Access
Teacher Education
Enhanced Network Teacher Education Capacity
Hubs for Connected Learning Initiatives
Education Pathways
Bard Microcollege for Just Community Leadership
Collaborative for Liberal Education for Adolescents
Consortium for the Liberal Arts in Prison
Hubs for Connected Learning Initiatives
Civic sub-menu
Civic Engagement
Student Engagement
Get Engaged Conference
Global Commons
Global Engagement Fellows
Engaged Learning
Certificate in Civic Engagement
Community Engaged Liberal Arts and Sciences
Community Engaged Research
Experiential Learning Institute
Solve Climate by 2030
Past Projects
Engaged Senior Projects
OSUN Science Shop
Academic Freedom sub-menu
Academic Freedom
Initiatives
AltLiberalArts
Invisible University for Ukraine
Smolny Beyond Borders
Threatened Scholars Integration Initiative
Institutional Partners
American University of Afghanistan
Parami University
News sub-menu
News + Opportunities
Newsroom
Current News
News Archive
Events
Current Events
Events Archive
Opportunities
For Students
For Faculty
Archive
Resources sub-menu
Resources
Digital Collection
Digital Case Studies
Digital Course Collection
Student-Produced Videos
Teaching Tools
About sub-menu
About
About OSUN
Our Vision
Who We Are
What We Do
Member Institutions
Themes
Annual Report
Branding
Search
Search
News & Events Menu
News & Events Menu
Newsroom
Current News
News Archive
Events
Current Events
Events Archive
Opportunities
Current Opportunities
Opportunities Archive
OSUN News
View all news
Therapy for the Polity? Making a Case for Citizens’ Assemblies
Kali Akuno, co-founder of Cooperation Jackson, traced the history of the Black assembly tradition in the American South at the Revitalizing Democracy conference. Photo by Karl Rabe.
Are elections actually bad for democracy? Might more participatory forms of deliberative democracy provide a way to help dissolve some of the gridlock around divisive issues such as climate change and police reform? These were some of the key themes recently explored during “
Revitalizing Democracy: Sortition, Citizen Power and Spaces of Freedom
,” a conference sponsored by OSUN’s
Hannah Arendt Humanities Network
(HAHN), a project based at Bard College that supports the integration and accessibility of humanities studies across OSUN institutions.
Bringing together activists, authors, scholars, local politicians, and students to explore the growing trend of citizens’ assemblies, the
conference
on the Bard campus in New York’s Hudson Valley attracted over 100 in-person attendees and over 400 online participants.
As explained in an opening panel discussion by author
David Van Reybrouck
, a specialist on
citizens’ assemblies
, elections and referendums are inherently divisive, and tend to “deliver one result, two divided communities.” Citizens’ assemblies, on the other hand, can enable local or national communities to work through their differences, providing a sort of “couples therapy” for the polity. Lasting a few days or several months, citizens’ assemblies convene anywhere from 30 to 150 randomly selected people for roundtable conversations that are facilitated by experienced moderators. After a period of deliberation and consultation with experts, the assembly then votes on final policy recommendations.
The tension between existing electoral democracy and more participatory alternatives was a key theme throughout the conference.
Roger Berkowitz
, leader of HAHN, reminded attendees that the aristocratic founders of the US political system considered elections a tool for maintaining elite control over a public that should not be trusted. Rather than encourage the type of popular participation exemplified by early American town halls, the US Constitution aimed to limit the engagement of ordinary, uneducated people. Berkowitz offered that citizens’ assemblies might instead be able to revive those “lost spaces of citizen freedom.”
The audience learned of multiple national assembly initiatives and their varying degrees of success.
Jane Suiter
, of Dublin University, reviewed the history of the
Irish citizens’ assemblies
on abortion rights and marriage equality, which led to major changes in the Irish Constitution.
Helene Landemore
, of Yale University, provided the additional example of France’s
National Climate Assembly
, which demonstrated the power of ordinary citizens to deliberate and even draft new laws, but which also lacked an effective enforcement mechanism. Landemore explained that while President Emmanuel Macron promised that the French Parliament would vote on the assembly’s 146 recommendations, the proposals were instead whittled down to a handful of legal changes, ultimately considered by citizens to be a betrayal of the process.
Masha Gessen discussing parallel polities. Photo by Karl Rabe.
While many speakers focused on state-led design of citizens assemblies by governments and experts,
Kali Akuno
and
Masha Gessen
spoke to the power of bottom-up organizing to reshape society from below or in parallel to existing institutions.
Akuno, co-founder of
Cooperation Jackson
, an emerging network of worker cooperatives in Jackson, Mississippi, warned against romanticizing early American democracy and citizenship, both of which deliberately excluded and exploited enslaved Black Americans. The American settler-colonial project had slavery as a key economic feature, and much of its anti-democratic design (e.g., the Senate and the Electoral College) continues to shape American politics, he said. Akuno traced the history of the Black assembly tradition in the American South, from the Reconstruction to the Council of Federated Organizations during the civil rights movement of the 60s and on to groups such as the
Jackson People’s Assembly
, founded in the 90s. Akuno stressed that democracy is something that needs to be practiced, and that without free time and economic resources, ordinary people would inevitably be excluded. Put in starker terms, he said that American democracy not only needs to be revitalized, it needs to be reborn.
Journalist, author, and activist
Masha Gessen
argued that even in so-called totalitarian societies, there always exists a parallel space where citizens can imagine and create pockets of a democratic society that might later blossom into larger movements. Gessen told the inspiring story of the Workers Defense Committee in Poland under communism during the 1980s, who, rather than retreating into internal exile, sought instead to convene in secret. There they assembled the underground publishers, councils, and independent universities that would later help seed the Solidarity workers’ movement.
David Van Reybrouck said citizens’ assemblies can enable communities to work through their differences.
In one of the conference’s more provocative moments, Van Reybrouck asked the audience to reflect on the roots of the extremism that led right-wing insurgents to raid the U.S Capitol in January 2021 in an attempt to overturn the 2020 Presidential election. He asked if one of the agitators had been given the chance to speak their mind at a citizens’ assembly, “a place where he could express himself and feel respected,” would such a person still storm the capitol? Referring to populist anger as a “gift wrapped in barbed wire,” Van Reybrouck asserted that “instead of running away from the barbed wire, we might try to disentangle it.”
Watch a recording of
Revitalizing Democracy
and find out more about the
Hannah Arendt Humanities Network
.
Revitalizing Democracy Conference Video
Post Date:
November 2, 2021