Skip to main content.
OSUN Menu
Education sub-menu
Education
OSUN Courses
Faculty
Graduate Programs
Certificate Programs
Mobility
Teaching
Birkbeck Summer School
Center for Liberal Arts and Sciences Pedagogy (CLASP)
Developing Teaching Professionals
Experiential Learning Institute
Global History Lab
Global Teaching Fellowship Program
GLOBALED
Curricula
CORUSUS
Economic Democracy Initiative
Experimental Humanities Collaborative Network
Global Studies
Hannah Arendt Humanities Network
Human Rights Program
Liberal Arts and Sciences Collaborative
Policy Labs
Professional Development Program for University Administrators
Strengthening the Core
Transnational Feminism, Solidarity, and Social Justice
Research sub-menu
Research
Research Projects
Community Engaged Research
The Democracy Institute
Economic Democracy Initiative
GEOHUB
Global Institute of Advanced Study
OSUN Forum on Democracy and Development
Research Creation Initiative
Fellowships
Chatham House Academy Fellowships
Global Scholars Academy
Past Projects
Interruptrr
Global Observatory on Academic Freedom
Open Society Research Platform
Access sub-menu
Access
Teacher Education
Enhanced Network Teacher Education Capacity
Hubs for Connected Learning Initiatives
Education Pathways
Bard Microcollege for Just Community Leadership
Collaborative for Liberal Education for Adolescents
Consortium for the Liberal Arts in Prison
Hubs for Connected Learning Initiatives
Civic sub-menu
Civic Engagement
Student Engagement
Get Engaged Conference
Global Commons
Global Engagement Fellows
Engaged Learning
Certificate in Civic Engagement
Community Engaged Liberal Arts and Sciences
Community Engaged Research
Experiential Learning Institute
Solve Climate by 2030
Past Projects
Engaged Senior Projects
OSUN Science Shop
Academic Freedom sub-menu
Academic Freedom
Initiatives
AltLiberalArts
Invisible University for Ukraine
Smolny Beyond Borders
Threatened Scholars Integration Initiative
Institutional Partners
American University of Afghanistan
Parami University
News sub-menu
News + Opportunities
Newsroom
Current News
News Archive
Events
Current Events
Events Archive
Opportunities
For Students
For Faculty
Archive
Resources sub-menu
Resources
Video Collection
Case Studies
Course Collection
Student-Produced Videos
Teaching Tools
About sub-menu
About
About OSUN
Our Vision
Who We Are
What We Do
Member Institutions
Themes
Annual Reports
Branding
Search
Search
News & Events Menu
News & Events Menu
Newsroom
Current News
News Archive
Events
Current Events
Events Archive
Opportunities
Current Opportunities
Opportunities Archive
OSUN News
View all news
An Opportunity for Growth: Embracing a Pedagogy of Failure
Photo by Riho Kitagawa
Three panelists from Allegheny College recently joined the Liberal Arts and Sciences Collaborative (LAS Collab) to share lessons learned from their influential 2023 article on "
Teaching the Inevitable: Embracing a Pedagogy of Failure.
"
Amelia Finaret, Lisa Whitenack,
and
Lydia Eckstein
have observed that within higher education, encountering failure is commonly seen as an inevitability when mastering new material. Still, many students fear failure and many faculty do not consistently build upon students’ difficulties in order to improve their learning experiences. Although faculty may communicate an acceptance of failure, there is frequently a gap between this message and the actual structure of courses and assignments that might enable failure to be used constructively.
“Most of us perhaps tend to associate failure with disappointment, shame, loss, setback, fear, sadness, and stress,” Whitenack explained. “Some might appreciate the progression, opportunity, and growth associated with failure, but the vast majority seem to gravitate towards the more challenging aspects of failure.”
For educators, the key question is how to leverage productive failure, recognizing that everyone will at some point encounter it and that failure can provide an opportunity for growth. In the university classroom, instructors tend to focus on rewarding correct answers and rely on high-stakes, end-of-semester assessments. According to Eckstein, not creating space within a course for students to productively fail can come across as disingenuous and may also negatively affect the mental health of students.
To support educators in encouraging and rewarding risk-taking, making mistakes, and failing as a way of growing, Finaret, Whitenack, and Eckstein offer three categories of possible actions. Whitenack discussed the importance of destigmatizing failure. “It’s useful to understand that failure is a tool and the classroom can be a safe space to do things differently,” Whitenack explained. She went on to advise faculty to share personal experiences of failure, discuss “imposter syndrome” and support students so they see failure as a learning opportunity.
Eckstein also explained how educators can give assignments built around revision and growth. “This idea that you must get it right the first time can be incredibly anxiety provoking, encourage sloppy and hasty work, and also seems too unrealistic. Things almost always involve a process of revision,” Eckstein reflected. “So we want to encourage iterative assignments.”
Finaret also suggested using alternative grading schemes. “We still need to give a final course grade, but we should rethink the way that we grade during the semester to both reduce student anxiety and provide additional opportunities for them to fail without failing the course or the assignment,” Finaret explained.
“We think it important to celebrate our imperfections,” Eckstein concluded. “Learning from failure is like the Japanese art form of
Kintsugi
, which is the practice of filling broken pottery with gold. The idea is that rather than trying to conceal imperfections, failures, and cracks, these should instead be highlighted and made more beautiful.”
Finaret, Whitenack, and Eckstein have curated a list of useful
resources
for embracing a pedagogy of failure, covering the three strategies of destigmatizing failure, assignments built around revision, growth, and process, and alternative grading schemes.
Post Date:
June 24, 2024